Health and Care Professions Council determination — review hearing

HCPTS orders John Smyth struck off after review of ear impression failures

An HCPTS review panel found John Smyth remained impaired and had provided no evidence of remediation. Its striking-off order applies from 30 December 2026.

MedicWatch editorial · Published 18 November 2026 · Updated 20 November 2026

Erasure (struck off the register)

Data last checked: 20 November 2026Report a correction

What does “struck off the register” mean?

The regulator directed removal from the register in this decision. The decision explains when the direction takes effect and any appeal provisions. Check the official register for the practitioner's current registration status.

Concerning John Smyth, hearing aid dispenser (Health and Care Professions Council HAD01188).

Decision date: 18 November 2026 · Hearing started 18 November 2026

In plain English

The HCPTS panel found that John Smyth remained impaired following earlier findings about an ear impression procedure that harmed a service user. At this review, it had no further evidence of reflection, training or remediation and found an ongoing risk of repetition. It ordered his name to be struck off from 30 December 2026, when the existing suspension expires.

Charges

The June 2026 final panel found failures when taking an ear impression on 6 August 2022, including failing to consider contraindications, record a near miss and medical history, and notify a line manager.

Findings

At this first review, the panel found fitness to practise remained impaired on both personal and public components. There was no further reflection, relevant training or evidence of remediation, and a continuing risk of repetition. It directed a striking-off order to apply from 30 December 2026, replacing the existing suspension when it expires.

Mitigating and aggravating factors

Mitigating factors

In relation to mitigating factors, the Panel acknowledged that the misconduct related to an isolated act, involved a genuine clinical error, that the Registrant had admitted the mistake made and had expressed remorse and concern for the harm caused to the service user.

Aggravating factors

In relation to aggravating factors, the Panel noted that actual harm had been caused to a vulnerable service user, that the Registrant had demonstrated incomplete insight and provided no evidence of remediation, which suggested an unresolved risk of repetition. The Panel also had concerns that the Registrant continued to disengage with the fitness to practise process.

Source

All facts on this page are drawn from the publicly published Health and Care Professions Council determination linked below. MedicWatch does not editorialise the regulator’s findings.

Spot something incorrect?

If a fact on this page is wrong, or you believe the page should not be published, please submit a correction or takedown request.

Choose what works for you. Your choices are remembered for 180 days and you can change them any time using Cookie settings.