Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service determination — substantive hearing
MPTS directs Dr Malcolm Duncan’s erasure following child abuse image conviction
The tribunal found impaired fitness to practise following an admitted conviction for downloading indecent images and videos of children. It directed erasure and immediate suspension.
MedicWatch editorial · Published 25 September 2026 · Updated 21 November 2026
Erasure (struck off the register)
Data last checked: 21 November 2026Report a correction
What does “struck off the register” mean?
The regulator directed removal from the register in this decision. The decision explains when the direction takes effect and any appeal provisions. Check the official register for the practitioner's current registration status.
Concerning Dr Malcolm Duncan, doctor (General Medical Council 3407882).
Decision date: 25 September 2026 · Hearing started 24 August 2026 and ended 25 September 2026
In plain English
The MPTS tribunal directed Dr Malcolm Duncan’s erasure after finding his fitness to practise impaired following a conviction involving downloaded child sexual abuse images and videos. It found insufficient insight and remediation and imposed immediate suspension. The tribunal rejected the suggestion that reliable evidence showed offending extending back to 2005. The erasure direction takes effect after the statutory notification period unless appealed; immediate suspension continues pending any appeal.
Charges
Dr Duncan admitted his conviction on 23 October 2025 at St Albans Magistrates’ Court for making indecent photographs or pseudo-photographs of a child, involving 5,084 Category C images and videos on or before 7 September 2023. The offence concerned downloading material, rather than producing images at source. He admitted the associated community order, five-year Sexual Harm Prevention Order and five-year police notification requirement.
Findings
The tribunal found all admitted allegations proved and fitness to practise impaired by reason of conviction. It found limited insight, insufficient remediation and a continuing high risk to public protection. It did not accept that reliable evidence established downloading as far back as 2005 or any extended offending timespan. It directed erasure on 25 September 2026 and immediate suspension from that day, revoking the prior interim suspension. The substantive order takes effect 28 days after deemed written service unless appealed; immediate suspension continues pending any appeal. Public identification was permitted after a privacy application was refused, while private matters remain redacted.
Mitigating and aggravating factors
Aggravating factors
The conduct was premeditated. Dr Duncan deliberately downloaded the images. He also searched for terms such as ‘XXX’ indicating he was actively looking for material depicting young people. Dr Duncan’s actions were a reckless disregard for professional standards. Dr Duncan knew, or ought to have known, that he is required to act professionally and avoid exploiting vulnerable people, even in his private life.
Source
All facts on this page are drawn from the publicly published Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service determination linked below. MedicWatch does not editorialise the regulator’s findings.
Spot something incorrect?
If a fact on this page is wrong, or you believe the page should not be published, please submit a correction or takedown request.